Can you trust an AI-written Friends Friday promotion?
We gave two local models the same fictional five-product offer and checked the drafts against the merchant’s approved price sheet. Use the same worksheet on your own landing page, email and checkout.
The approved offer
Juniper Paper Co. runs Friends Friday on November 27, 2026, from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern. FRIENDS20 gives 20% off three products, one code per order. The gift card and pen stay at full price.
| Product | Regular | Approved checkout price |
|---|---|---|
| Notebook | $20 | $16 |
| Desk pad | $30 | $24 |
| Card set | $15 | $12 |
| Gift card | $25 | $25 |
| Brass pen | $40 | $40 |
Orders placed by noon Eastern on December 14 qualify for holiday dispatch. Arrival is unguaranteed. The merchant approved no free shipping, pickup or extra gifts.
What the two models produced
Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct got all three sale prices right. Its email also kept the gift card at $25 and the pen at $40, but printed FRIENDS20 next to both. It turned “one code per order” into a one-item limit, labeled the 9 a.m. opening as a deadline and omitted the 6 p.m. close and December dispatch cutoff. Its storefront listed only three products and its email subject was blank.
SmolLM2-1.7B-Instruct got none of the three sale prices into the draft. It repeated a 20%-off-your-order headline with FRIENDS20 until the generation limit. It supplied no product lines, exclusions, sale window or dispatch cutoff.
Merchant decision. Neither draft was ready to publish. Qwen’s arithmetic was usable in this run. An editor still needed the offer sheet to correct the conditions, write the subject and check a mixed cart.
Method, model versions and raw drafts
One fictional offer, one identical prompt, two local instruction-tuned models. We used Q4_K_M weights in llama-cpp-python 0.3.37 on CPU with greedy decoding, a 1,536-token context and a fixed seed. Both models reached an initial 370-token output limit. We repeated the test with an 800-token limit: Qwen finished, and SmolLM2 continued repeating. The findings use the longer run. This is one task with these model versions.
Download the prompt and all four raw drafts · Qwen model · SmolLM2 model · SmolLM2 quantization
How we rewrote the promotion
Five desk favorites for Friends Friday
On November 27, 9 a.m.–6 p.m. Eastern, use FRIENDS20 at checkout for the $16 notebook, $24 desk pad or $12 card set. The $25 gift card and $40 brass pen stay full price. One code per order.
Shop the Friends Friday collection. Order by December 14 at noon Eastern to qualify for holiday dispatch. Arrival dates are not guaranteed.
Email subject
Friday only: three paper goods from $12
Our Friends Friday sale runs November 27 from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern. Use FRIENDS20 once per order for the notebook, desk pad or card set. Gift cards and brass pens stay full price. Shop the collection. For holiday dispatch, order by noon Eastern on December 14. Arrival dates are not guaranteed.
Editorial correction for this fictional offer.Try the mixed-cart check
Put one of each product in the cart during the promotion and apply FRIENDS20. What subtotal should checkout show before tax and shipping?
Check your own promotion
Replace the example values with yours. Compare the offer sheet to the storefront, email and a test cart containing both eligible and excluded items. Save a screenshot of the total before a campaign goes live.
Download the campaign audit ↓Open the EcomCoach holiday plan. To repeat the exercise with other models in one browser interface, use ChatPlayground. We ran this test locally.
We may earn a commission through links marked “Affiliate link.” How we choose tools.
Record your decision
Choose an outcome for this comparison. In your Waymaker project, open Connected work and choose “Record an observation” to keep your reasons, owner and retest date.