VOICE AI BUYER TEST · NOVEMBER 18, 2026

What happens when an AI receptionist takes the after-hours call?

Compare Vapi and ElevenAgents on the same five fictional HVAC calls. Start with monthly cost, then check whether the office actually receives the right callback or booking.

What 100 calls could cost

300 minutes · Vapi $26.94–$41.07 · ElevenAgents $24.00 plus any unentered charges

Vapi’s example combines its $0.05/minute platform fee, transcription ($0.0095–$0.0099), model ($0.0077–$0.0452), voice ($0.0146–$0.0238) and an illustrative $0.008 inbound carrier rate. ElevenAgents uses the recurring $22 Creator plan, 275 included minutes and $0.08 per additional minute. Add your own model and carrier rates above. Numbers are monthly USD estimates; phone numbers, taxes, transfers, plan discounts and optional services can change the bill.

Vapi pricing calculator · ElevenAgents pricing

Set up a fair trial

Give both agents the same fictional service boundary, opening hours, callback policy, calendar and two test recipients. Use a test calendar with a single Tuesday 10 a.m. slot. Supply test numbers, let participants know when recording is enabled, and route calls only to participants.

  1. Routine callback. Request a tune-up. Does a named queue receive the correct callback?
  2. Booking conflict. Take the last slot just before confirmation. Does the agent offer a valid alternative?
  3. Corrected number. Change the last digit. Compare the final read-back and delivered ticket.
  4. Outside the service area. Ask for tonight. Check that the reply follows the written boundary.
  5. Unanswered handoff. Let the first alert expire. Check the backup’s acknowledgment and ticket count.
Download the five-call scorecard ↓

The scorecard has a row for each case on each platform. Record a test recording or transcript reference, the delivered ticket and its recipient. A false booking, wrong callback number or lost handoff calls for a fix and a rerun.

Where the evidence stands

Pricing and test design reviewed November 18. No matched calls have been completed. Recordings, transcripts, measured call charges and a performance verdict are pending.

Explore Vapi · Explore ElevenAgents · Read the HVAC handoff guide

If you run a trade business and want a packaged receptionist, OnCrew is a third option to scope. Ask for the included minutes and overage in writing before comparing it with the estimates above.

We may earn a commission through links marked “Affiliate link.” How we choose tools.

Bring it to your team

Download the missed-inquiry project brief or discuss an implementation scope with Waymaker Agency. South Florida teams can volunteer for a local handoff pilot.

Record your decision

Choose an outcome for this comparison. In your Waymaker project, open Connected work and choose “Record an observation” to keep your reasons, owner and retest date.